Showing posts with label Eclipse Awards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Eclipse Awards. Show all posts

Monday, December 27, 2010

The 2010 Eclipse Awards

We don't get an Eclipse Award ballot...but we should! Okay, we shouldn't. But we see no reason not to wrap up a season of horse racing by putting forth who we think should get the Eclipse Awards in the major horse racing categories. We're going to fill these out 1-2-3, because in some cases, it's worth tipping the cap to those who had good years but not spectacular years. Let's get to it.

2yo fillies

With the 2 year olds, it's tough to not vote for the Breeders Cup winner unless it's a bomb, a la Vale of York last year. Awesome Feather was undefeated and beat all the opposition of note in the Breeders Cup, so she wins here easily over R Heat Lightning, who ran second in the JF Fillies. We'll give the third slot to More Than Real, who won the JF Turf.

1. Awesome Feather 2. R Heat Lightning 3. More Than Real

2yo colts

If Uncle Mo doesn't win this unanimously, the defecting voters should be publicly humiliated. Boys at Toscanova won the Hopeful and ran second in the Juvenile and is an easy silver medalist. For third place, we'll go with To Honor and Serve, who's the second choice in Derby future books now off his wins in the Nashua and Remsen.

1. Uncle Mo 2. Boys at Toscanova 3. To Honor and Serve

3yo colts

Lookin at Lucky won the Preakness, Haskell, Rebel and Indiana Derby, and really only ran one bad race all year (the Kentucky Derby, over a sloppy mess). While we think Eskendereya was the most talented horse, LAL was the most accomplished and takes this easily.

Who else finishes out the ballot? We can't really go with Eskendereya who didn't race after Easter. Super Saver and Drosselmeyer look like 1-race flukes and are out. So let's go a little out of the box. Paddy O'Prado ran a bang-up 3rd in the Derby and won the Secretariat and was probably the best turfer of this class. For the 3rd slot, we'll go with Sidney's Candy, who quietly won five graded stakes this year but flopped against top class in the BC Mile and Derby.

1. Lookin at Lucky 2. Paddy O'Prado 3. Sidney's Candy

3yo fillies

This was neck and neck between Havre de Grace and Blind Luck all year but Blind Luck's place finish in the Distaff clinched her the title over a pretty good foe. We'll give the third slot to Switch, who came close to Zenyatta, was an excellent 2nd in the Filly Sprint and just won impressively in the La Brea last Sunday.

1. Blind Luck 2. Havre de Grace 3. Switch

Older Males

Blame won the Classic and wins this easily. Quality Road won the Donn, Met Mile and Woodward and was the best horse in the country through Memorial Day, so he gets second place. There are zero interesting options for third place, as Richard's Kid's two Grade 1 wins in California bore us to tears, Battle Plan retired too early, Haynesfield and Dakota Phone each won exactly one race of consequence and Gio Ponti was 2-for-7 this year. I guess Richard's Kid? Sure.

1. Blame 2. Quality Road 3. Richard's Kid

Older Females

What's amazing is that Rachel Alexandra isn't even one of the 5 horses we'd consider for a slot here. The top slot is easy and Unrivaled Belle tops Life at Ten in the balloting for winning the biggest race of the year. But we want to include on our ballot the horse with the second most G1 wins in America this year: Proviso. We'll talk more about her in a few minutes.

1. Zenyatta 2. Proviso 3. Unrivaled Belle

Turf Males

Blech. Gio Ponti was 2-for-7 this year with his best race probably being his 2nd place finish in the Mile. Winchester won 2 Grade 1's this year but both were at Belmont over middling competition. Dangerous Midge did win the Turf, but that's all he won this year. Paddy O'Prado would have been interesting had he even beaten older horses, but he never did. We were tempting to register a protest vote for Turf Sprint winner Chamberlain Bridge, and then remembered he wasn't very good.

When in doubt, take the Breeders Cup winner. That's what we're going with.

1. Dangerous Midge 2. Gio Ponti 3. Winchester

Turf Females

Shared Account gets the third slot here based off her win in the F&M Turf. The debate for the top spot is between Proviso's body of work--4 Grade 1 wins, including one over Shared Account--versus Goldikova's lone G1 win in the Mile. We're not taking into account her prior accomplishments because Eclipse Awards are only based off what a horse did this year. But still, Goldikova won four Grade 1's across the globe this year, won the Mile handily, and beat Proviso in the process. In fact, it wasn't close. Good enough.

1. Goldikova 2. Proviso 3. Shared Account

Female Sprinter

Dubai Majesty's win in the Filly Sprint gives her this easily. We can't find much better than the aforementioned Switch or 3yo filly Champagne d'Oro, who won the Acorn and Test, so we'll put them in the other slots.

1. Dubai Majesty 2. Switch 3. Champagne d'Oro

Male Sprinter

The question is Majesticperfection versus Big Drama. The former beat Big Drama in the Vanderbilt before retiring with an injury. Since then, Big Drama ran a bang-up second in the Forego--at 7 furlongs, not 6--and won the BC Sprint easily. On the rest of the year, he won the Smile Sprint and an ungraded race, whereas Majesticperfection won...well, a race in Iowa, a maiden race, and two allowance races. In other words, not much.

Can you justify taking Big Drama when he lost their only heads up battle? If the campaigns and accomplishments are roughly equivalent, absolutely not. But we don't think they are and think that the balance of Big Drama's year offsets the loss in the Vanderbilt. And we'll give him the vote. For 3rd, Discreetly Mine was the best 3yo sprinter this year by a lot.

1. Big Drama 2. Majesticperfection 3. Discreetly Mine

Trainer

Is there any way Todd Pletcher loses this after winning the Derby, 2 Breeders Cup races and a total of 14 Grade 1's? Didn't think so. For the place slot, many would go with John Shirreffs for his work on Zenyatta and Harmonious, but John Sadler won seven Grade 1's with different horses. That's pretty damn good.

1. Todd Pletcher 2. John Sadler 3. John Shirreffs

Jockey

The rider with the most G1's is Mike Smith (12), but he got 75% of them on Proviso and Zenyatta. Not interested. By contrast, John Velazquez and Garrett Gomez rode a bunch of different horses to G1 victories and were the best big-money riders in the nation. We also like Joel Rosario winning 10 Grade 1's on 10 different horses--very impressive.

1. Garrett Gomez 2. John Velazquez 3. Joel Rosario

Owner

The Mosses will win this in a romp for keeping Zenyatta in training this year. The owner that probably had the best year was WinStar, which won the Derby and Belmont, but we're fine with honoring the owners that gave racing the best press. For the third slot...sheesh, I dunno, how about Mike Pegram?

1. Jerry & Ann Moss 2. WinStar Farms 3. Mike Pegram

Horse of the Year

The great debate: Zenyatta versus Blame. Okay, last year's was a better debate between Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta because the two never faced. We think this year's debate is really easy: how can you not vote for Blame when he beat Zenyatta in their head-to-head matchup? Here are the arguments for Zenyatta, none of which hold water:
  • Her career accomplishments. Completely irrelevant. It's Horse of the Year, not Horse of the Career.
  • Her publicity to racing. So? It's a question of who accomplished more this year, not who had racing in the press more. If fame and publicity were a factor, Barbaro would have won in 2006 by a mile. He wasn't even close.
  • She came close in the Classic. Indeed, I think many of us appreciated Zenyatta more after the Classic even though she lost. But she still lost to Blame. If she had lost to Etched, this would be a different story on a couple of levels.
  • She had a better year. Essentially, this is the Big Drama/Majesticperfection argument all over again. The argument is that Zenyatta had a better year because she won 5 Grade 1's to Blame's 3, and won at 4 racetracks to his 3. (This completely ignores the fact that 3 of her races were in Southern California...but whatever.) But let's break this down a little, because this is really the question. Zenyatta won 5 races against fillies and mares only. Blame won 4 races and 3 Grade 1's in open company. He beat top caliber horses, such as Quality Road, Battle Plan, Fly Down, Lookin at Lucky and Haynesfield. The best horse that Zenyatta beat in her non-Classic races was either Switch or St. Trinians, either of which would have been 50-1 in the Classic and a non-factor.
To everyone who thinks that it's a blemish on her resume for Zenyatta to have never won HOTY, it's not. Ruffian never won it. Personal Ensign never won it. Goldikova, who's the best filly to race stateside in a decade, never won it. It happens. And Blame should be the winner.

1. Blame 2. Zenyatta 3. Quality Road

Thursday, December 24, 2009

Horses of the Decades Part I: The Females

We had intended to write something about the horses of the decade. And then, Daily Racing Form blogger, publisher, columnist and racing aficionado Steve Crist threw down the gauntlet:
Your mission, should you choose to accept it, is to share your thoughts on which Eclipse Award winners of the soon-to-be-over 2000's were the very best of the decade, division by division. I'll make my final choices next week and the results are scheduled to be published in the DRF newspaper of January 2, 2010.
While we could simply list a bunch of horses in the comments section, there are some interesting debates to be had in many of these categories, and we're suckers for reminiscing about a decade of horse racing. So let's take up Steve's challenge and break down the 10 categories for decade-long Eclipse awards. In Part I, we'll break down the awards to females: 2yo, 3yo, 4yo+ and turf filly. In Part II, we'll break down the awards for males (same groups) and top sprinter. In Part III, we'll see who has a case for Horse of the Decade.

2 year old filly

3 horses won the Eclipse Award in this category solely because they won the Breeders' Cup Juvenile Fillies: Caressing in 2000, Tempera (2001) and Dreaming of Anna (2006). As they lack a real championship campaign, they're out of contention, along with whoever wins this year (probably She Be Wild).

Indian Blessing (2007) has had probably the best career out of all of these horses. However, solely looking at her 2 year old campaign (which we think is our charge, at least for the 2yos and 3yos, given that's how they awarded the Eclipse), she ran only 3 times and won the Breeders Cup in the mud where nobody fired. She's out too.

Halfbridled (2003), Sweet Catomine (2004) and Folklore (2005) were all nice horses with strikingly similar campaigns: all had 3 graded stakes wins that included a Grade 2, a non-Breeders Cup Grade 1, and the Breeders Cup JF. They all also have small bonus points in their favor: Folklore won another race and was never worse than second, Halfbridled's Breeders Cup win was probably the most impressive given she started from the deadly outside post, and Sweet Catomine was the most impressive looking on the track. Still, they're pretty tough to separate from each other, and unlike two other horses, lack the third G1 win. So let's look at the real two contenders:

--Storm Flag Flying (2002). Won three Grade 1's in her two year old season: the Matron, Frizette and Breeders Cup JF in a scintillating victory where she was passed in the stretch and came back. Until Zenyatta's Classic win, it was a contender for best BC moment this decade.

--Stardom Bound (2008). Hard to remember now, but at the beginning of this year, this was the three-year-old filly everyone was talking about, and not Rachel Alexandra. And with good reason. She won three G1's in California last year, including the BC JF, in a rallying style like Sweet Catomine but with a hair more panache. All of her stakes wins were authoritative, and everyone thought she'd be a superstar this year. (Sadly, injury kept that from happening.)

At the end of the day, SFF's Breeders Cup win was one of the most impressive this decade, and she did leave California to win a race. That tips the scale slightly in her favor over Stardom Bound. For the third slot, we'll give it to Halfbridled, who beat Ashado in the Breeders Cup (we'll get to her in a minute), won for fun from an outside post on BC day, and could have been a great one had she stayed healthy.

Eclipse Ballot: 1. Storm Flag Flying; 2. Stardom Bound; 3. Halfbridled .

3yo filly

Rachel Alexandra, who will win the 2009 Eclipse for this category in a walk, takes this category for the decade in a walk as well. Her 8-for-8 season with two wins over 3yo males, older males and 40+ lengths of wins in the Kentucky Oaks and Mother Goose is one of the best seasons ever by a filly. It's not worth debating too much, so let's instead ask: who get the other two slots on the ballot?

Let's dispense with the uninteresting ones quickly. Smuggler (2004) is one of the worst Eclipse winners this decade, winning in a year where nobody really put together a solid campaign. Wait a While (2006) and Xtra Heat (2001) won despite being specialists (turfing and sprinting, respectively) because like Smuggler, they succeeded in down years, and while both were neat horses, neither had the resume to be at the top. Farda Amiga (2002) and Proud Spell (2008) had markedly similar seasons with wins in the Kentucky Oaks and Alabama and some other decent showings, and while good, remain a level below the elite. This leaves us with three real contenders for the silver and bronze:

--Surfside (2000) dominated in a winter of 2000 with a pair of G1's (SA Oaks and Las Virgines), took the summer off, then came back to run a good 2nd in the Breeders Cup Distaff and beat the boys in the Clark Handicap. A win over older males means a lot, but the season was a hair odd and erratic.

--Ashado (2004) had an 8 start season with 3 big wins (Kentucky Oaks, CC American Oaks and BC Distaff), a pair of minor wins (Cotillion and Fair Ground Oaks) and a troika of excusable losses (Ashland to speedball Madcap Escapade, Mother Goose to the underrated Stellar Jayne and Alabama when she chased the pace and was caught by Society Selection). One of the better horses to run this decade, if forgotten in the wake of Zenyatta and Rachel Alexandra.

--Rags to Riches (2007) is here based on two wins: a dominating win in the Kentucky Oaks and being the first filly to take the Belmont since Teddy Roosevelt was President. There wasn't too much of a campaign beyond that, but when you win the Belmont, you may not need one.

Based on the entire campaign, Ashado (left) clearly had the second-best 3yo filly season: a full 8-race campaign, ran at 7 tracks, and beat older females. We're going to be in the minority here and take Surfside for the third slot; we don't like that Rags to Riches only ran once again after the Belmont and lost the race. Longevity in the campaign does mean a lot.

Eclipse Ballot: 1. Rachel Alexandra; 2. Ashado; 3. Surfside.

Older Fillies and Mares

There are only seven horses to pick from here, as Azeri won three times (2002-2004) and Zenyatta won in 2008 and is a cinch to win it this year. We'll dispense with trying to make a case for Gourmet Girl (2001), Fleet Indian (2006), or Ginger Punch (2007): Gourmet Girl won by default in a horrible year, and Ginger Punch and Fleet Indian are the 5-6 finishers here in some order. We'll also give the above-mentioned Ashado kudos for a nice four year old season while noting that she's clearly the #4 of this group based on her older horse campaign.

How we judge this category actually turns on whether the question is best season or best career. Because if we're simply going by best season, the unheralded Riboletta (2000) is a real contender to dethrone Azeri and Zenyatta. In 2000, Riboletta dominated on both coasts with 5 G1 wins and 3 G2 wins. She entered the Breeders Cup Distaff as a 2-5 favorite that was everyone's lock of the day...and promptly bombed and finished well out of the money. Had she won the Distaff or even finished a strong second, she'd win the "best campaign" hands down.

While we're at it, let's check out the 5 Azeri and Zenyatta campaigns, just to help us split these two up a little:

Azeri '02: After winning a restricted race, she ran second in a G2 then ran off seven straight wins, incluing 5 Grade 1's (one of which was the BC Distraff) and 2 Grade 2's. While she was named Horse of the Year, that was in part because there were no good male horses that year. Indeed, her campaign, outside of the Breeders Cup win, is pretty similar to Riboletta's 2000 season.

Azeri '03: Started off the year with 3 G1's, then won a G2 in California before losing the Lady's Secret to the immortal Got Koko and getting injured before the Breeders Cup. She almost lost this Eclipse to Sightseek; you can't make a case this was her best year.

Azeri '04: D. Wayne Lukas took over her campaign from Laura DeSeroux with some truly odd results. She won the Apple Blossom, Spinster and Go For Wand (all G1's), but lost the Humana Distaff, Ogden Phipps (finishing 4th!) and Personal Ensign. On top of that, she had two starts against males where she was never competitive. Again, far below the '02 season, but kinda neat in retrospect.

Zenyatta '08: 7-for-7 all year (4 G1's, 3 G2's), a win outside of California where she annihilated the previous year's Eclipse winner (Ginger Punch) and true dominance on Breeders Cup day. Contender.

Zenyatta '09: A boring campaign is rounded out by a stellar BC Classic win. One win does not make a season, even if it was one of the greatest wins in BC history.

So what to do? We think that the Eclipse Award for the non-2yo and 3yo categories really should look at a horse's entire body of work. Based on that, Riboletta isn't a contender, as Azeri and Zenyatta tower over her. Still, we do want to note that if we did it based on a single season, she'd win. She was THAT dominant in 2000; nobody came near her until she flopped at Churchill Downs.

As for Azeri versus Zenyatta...this is not an easy debate. Azeri ran around the country, took on all comers, and put together two excellent years and one interesting year. But Zenyatta was undefeated and won the Breeders Cup Classic. You can't argue with perfection. Only Personal Ensign can match her undefeated record, her consistency, and her panache. And that makes her the top pick.

Eclipse Award ballot: 1. Zenyatta; 2. Azeri; 3. Riboletta

Turf Filly

The bias here is going to be fairly high in favor of European based horses, because, with all due respect, horses like Forever Together (2008), Lahudood (2007), Perfect Sting (2000) and Golden Apples (2002) campaigned against American horses and ran almost exclusively other fillies. While there's nothing wrong with that, European fillies raise the bar by routinely take on the boys and win. Their records may be less perfect than their American counterparts, but that goes part and parcel with facing tougher competition. If they repeatedly ran against the likes of Snow Polina and Megahertz, we're confident in arguing that they would have near perfect records.

For example, let's look at the 2003 Eclipse winner, Islington. That year, Islington had two wins and two thirds in six starts, which looks mediocre on its face. But in that campaign, she ran third to High Chapparal and Falbrav in one race (who ran 1-3 in the BC Turf that year), ran third to a pair of Euro studs in Nayef and Rakti earlier that year, and her two off-the-board finishes were a 3-length loss to males and a silly trip to Japan in December. We know results matter. But that's a mile more impressive than Perfect Sting racing against fillies that would be 200-1 against Falbrav.

As impressive as Islington's 2003 campaign was, she's not a contender for the top slot. Ouija Board (right) wins this category hands down based on both the best individual season (2004) and her entire career. Let's sum up a filly that will be mentioned in the Horse of the Decade argument in a few days:

--In 2004, her 3yo season (the best season by any Eclipse winner in this category), she ran five times and won 4 starts, including the BC Filly & Mare Turf, the Irish Oaks and the English Oaks. What's even more impressive is her one loss was a third place finish in Europe's biggest race, the Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe. Yowks.

--Her next two seasons had "only" 5 wins in 14 starts. But the quality of those wins--damn. They include 4 Grade 1's, ranging from the F&M Turf, the Hong Kong Vase (!), the Nassau Stakes and Prince of Wales Stakes; all races of great import. Her other in the money finishes include the Japan Cup, Irish Champion Stakes, Coronation Cup, QEII Cup, and 2005 F&M Turf as well. She competed against the best and more than held her own. That merits the top spot in this division, and she's arguably the best turf filly to run in this country since Miesque.

--Her 2006 trip to the Breeders Cup resulted in Lord Derby coming to Churchill Downs for the race. His pre-race interview where he mocked how we pronounced the word "Derby" while sporting some horrible teeth was a highlight of the racing season.

After Ouija Board, for the rest of the ballot, it's a question of who you take a shine to between the aforementioned Islington, Banks Hill (2001) and Goldikova (2009, probably). Our personal preference goes to Goldikova for the place slot, based on her two BC Mile wins and her dominance on both sides of the pond (her losses in 2008 were to Zarkava, one of the best fillies this decade period), and Islington, who would have won two straight F&M Turfs but for Kieran Fallon's execrable ride in 2002. Banks Hill, while very good and dominating in the 2001 F&M Turf, lacked the overall je no se qua of the other two and seems to coast by on being out of super-mother Hasili.

Eclipse Award ballot: 1. Ouija Board; 2. Goldikova; 3. Islington

Coming up on Saturday: the males and sprinters.